Back to blog
InvestingUnited States

ETF total return vs price return

3 min read14 November 2026By FinTarget Team

Work through a fictional US ETF’s price change and cash distribution to see how reinvestment changes the total return.

In this article

An ETF’s price return measures the change in its share price over a period. Total return includes distributions as well. A published fund total return typically assumes that distributions buy more shares at the specified reinvestment price. Your brokerage account can show a different result if you took the cash, bought on different dates or paid different prices.

Calculate the price change and cash received

Suppose you own 100 shares of a fictional US ETF priced at USD 100 per share at the start of the year. At the end of the year the price is USD 104. The price return is 4%, calculated as (104 − 100) ÷ 100. Your 100 shares rise in value from USD 10,000 to USD 10,400.

Now suppose the fund pays a single distribution of USD 3 per share midyear. If you keep the USD 300 in cash and it earns nothing for the rest of the year, your year-end position consists of USD 10,400 in shares and USD 300 in cash. That is USD 10,700 in total, or 7.00% above the starting value. The example assumes no other cash flows, fees or taxes.

Follow the reinvestment assumption

For the reinvested version, assume the distribution buys shares at USD 100 and that the same end price of USD 104 applies. The USD 300 buys three extra shares, giving you 103. At year end the shares together are worth USD 10,712. The total return with reinvestment is 7.12%. The extra USD 12 comes from the three reinvested shares rising by USD 4 each.

The reinvestment price affects how many shares the distribution buys. Whether the extra shares add more or less to the ending value than the original cash depends on the price change after reinvestment. If a chart already adjusts its figures for distributions, adding the distributions to that change again can count them twice. Look for a description of what the chart adjusts and which dates it uses.

Match market prices and fund values

An ETF’s net asset value, or NAV, is the value of the fund’s assets minus its liabilities, expressed per share. It can differ from the exchange price you paid. SEC staff guidance explains that performance tables in US fund shareholder reports use NAV. An ETF provider’s other materials can also show a market-price series. A comparison between returns makes more sense when both use the same basis, the same period and the same treatment of distributions.

A distribution yield measures distributions relative to a price or NAV using the source’s stated period and method. In the simplified example, the USD 3 payment is 3% of the USD 100 starting price, and the reinvested total return is 7.12%. The 3% figure describes the distribution relative to that price. The total includes the price change and what happened to the shares bought with the payment.

If you are reconciling a brokerage statement, keep the cash distribution, any reinvestment purchase and the ending share count together. Under the cash example, the broker record should show 100 shares plus USD 300 received. Under the reinvestment example, it should show a purchase of three extra shares using the distribution. Those entries explain why the accounts end at different values even though the ETF’s ending price is the same. The cash record also shows the exact date the broker credited the payment.

Put it into practice

Record your holdings, dividends, income and expenses in FinTarget. Free to get started, with no bank connection.

Get started free